Skip to content
Infinite Craft Recipes

How to Make I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter in Infinite Craft

I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter is a long haul. Even on the shortest known route it takes 39 combinations to get there, and the final one is Margarine plus Past Tense. Expect to build several intermediate elements you will never use again.

The final combination

MargarinePast TenseI Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter

Marathon39 steps from the base elementscrafting depth 574 known recipes

Full crafting path from the base elements

Start with Water, Fire, Wind and Earth, then follow these 39 combinations in order.

  1. 1EarthWindDust
  2. 2DustEarthPlanet
  3. 3EarthPlanetMoon
  4. 4FireWaterSteam
  5. 5EarthSteamMud
  6. 6MoonMudCheese
  7. 7CheeseWaterMilk
  8. 8MilkWindButter
  9. 9FireWindSmoke
  10. 10SmokeWaterFog
  11. 11FogPlanetVenus
  12. 12ButterVenusMargarine
  13. 13DustFireAsh
  14. 14WaterWindWave
  15. 15EarthWaveSand
  16. 16FireSandGlass
  17. 17GlassSandHourglass
  18. 18FireHourglassTime
  19. 19AshTimeHistory
  20. 20GlassSteamMirror
  21. 21HistoryMirrorPast
  22. 22EarthWaterPlant
  23. 23FogPlantMushroom
  24. 24EarthMushroomToadstool
  25. 25PlantWindDandelion
  26. 26DandelionPlantWeed
  27. 27ToadstoolWeedMagic Mushroom
  28. 28DustWindSandstorm
  29. 29SandstormWaterOasis
  30. 30OasisPlantDate
  31. 31DateWaterDating
  32. 32DatingEarthMarriage
  33. 33EarthMarriageDivorce
  34. 34DandelionDustWish
  35. 35WaterWishGenie
  36. 36DivorceGenieSingle
  37. 37Magic MushroomSingleTriple
  38. 38PastTriplePast Tense
  39. 39MargarinePast TenseI Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter
Crafting tree
1Earth + Wind→ Dust2Dust + Earth→ Planet3Earth + Planet→ Moon4Fire + Water→ Steam5Earth + Steam→ Mud6Moon + Mud→ Cheese7Cheese + Water→ Milk8Milk + Wind→ Butter9Fire + Wind→ Smoke10Smoke + Water→ Fog11Fog + Planet→ Venus12Butter + Venus→ Margarine13Dust + Fire→ Ash14Water + Wind→ Wave15Earth + Wave→ Sand16Fire + Sand→ Glass17Glass + Sand→ Hourglass18Fire + Hourglass→ Time19Ash + Time→ History20Glass + Steam→ Mirror21History + Mirror→ Past22Earth + Water→ Plant23Fog + Plant→ Mushroom24Earth + Mushroom→ Toadstool25Plant + Wind→ Dandelion26Dandelion + Plant→ Weed27Toadstool + Weed→ Magic Mushroom28Dust + Wind→ Sandstorm29Sandstorm + Water→ Oasis30Oasis + Plant→ Date31Date + Water→ Dating32Dating + Earth→ Marriage33Earth + Marriage→ Divorce34Dandelion + Dust→ Wish35Water + Wish→ Genie36Divorce + Genie→ Single37Magic Mushroom + Single→ Triple38Past + Triple→ Past Tense39Margarine + Past Tense→ I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter

Other ways to make I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter

4 combinations are known to produce I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter. Here are 4 of them.

Alternative combinations that produce I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter
FirstSecondResult
MargarinePast TenseI Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter
MargarinePast tenseI Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter
InitialsSunflower OilI Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter
InitialsMargarineI Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter

I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter at a glance

Steps to craft
39
Marathon
Crafting depth
57
longer than 97% of solved elements
Known recipes
4
ways to make it
Used in
0
other combinations

Other elements that take 39 steps

Similar effort to I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter, if you want something else to chase.

Frequently asked questions

How do you make I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter in Infinite Craft?

Combine Margarine with Past Tense. The full path from the base elements takes 39 steps.

How many steps does it take to make I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter?

39 steps on the shortest known path from Water, Fire, Wind and Earth.

Is I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter hard to make in Infinite Craft?

It rates as marathon. At 39 steps it is longer than 97% of solved elements.

Is there more than one way to make I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter?

Yes. 4 combinations are known to produce I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter, and the shortest route is shown above.

Path verified against the open recipe graph on . Method described in our methodology, data credited on data sources.