Home / Recipes / Past Doubter ๐ How to Make Past Doubter in Infinite CraftPast Doubter is a long haul. Even on the shortest known route it takes 54 combinations to get there, and the final one is Doubter plus Past Tense. Expect to build several intermediate elements you will never use again.
The final combination
๐ค Doubter+ ๐ค Past Tense= ๐ Past Doubter
Marathon 54 steps from the base elements ยท crafting depth 80 ยท 2 known recipes
๐ Copy steps
What is worth knowing At 54 steps it is longer than 99% of solved elements, which puts it in our marathon band. Only 2 known combinations produce Past Doubter, so there is very little room to improvise. Follow the path exactly. Its crafting depth of 80 is unusually deep. Depth counts the longest chain needed to reach it, and most elements people search for sit well below this. Full crafting path from the base elements Start with Water, Fire, Wind and Earth, then follow these 54 combinations in order.
1 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐ง Water= ๐จ Steam2 ๐ Earth+ ๐จ Steam= ๐ฉ Mud3 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐ฉ Mud= ๐งฑ Brick4 ๐ Earth+ ๐ง Water= ๐ฑ Plant5 ๐ฑ Plant+ ๐จ Wind= ๐ผ Dandelion6 ๐ผ Dandelion+ ๐ง Water= ๐ท Wine7 ๐ง Water+ ๐ท Wine= ๐ฆ Holy Water8 ๐งฑ Brick+ ๐ฆ Holy Water= โช Church9 ๐ Earth+ ๐จ Wind= ๐ซ๏ธ Dust10 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐จ Steam= ๐ Engine11 ๐ซ๏ธ Dust+ ๐ Engine= ๐งน Vacuum12 ๐งน Vacuum+ ๐ง Water= ๐งฝ Sponge13 ๐งฝ Sponge+ ๐จ Steam= ๐ SpongeBob14 ๐ Earth+ ๐ SpongeBob= ๐ Patrick15 ๐ Engine+ ๐จ Steam= ๐ Train16 ๐ Patrick+ ๐ Train= ๐ Thomas17 โช Church+ ๐ Thomas= ๐ค Doubt18 ๐ฑ Plant+ ๐ง Water= ๐ Swamp19 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐ Swamp= ๐ Dragon20 ๐ง Water+ ๐จ Wind= ๐ Wave21 ๐ Earth+ ๐ Wave= ๐๏ธ Sand22 ๐๏ธ Sand+ ๐ง Water= ๐๏ธ Beach23 ๐ซ๏ธ Dust+ ๐ Earth= ๐ช Planet24 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐ช Planet= โ๏ธ Sun25 ๐๏ธ Beach+ โ๏ธ Sun= ๐๏ธ Vacation26 ๐ Engine+ ๐๏ธ Vacation= ๐ด Retirement27 ๐ Earth+ ๐ด Retirement= ๐ต Pension28 ๐ Dragon+ ๐ต Pension= ๐ค Retired29 ๐ค Doubt+ ๐ค Retired= ๐ค Doubter30 ๐ซ๏ธ Dust+ ๐ฅ Fire= ๐ Ash31 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐๏ธ Sand= ๐ฅ Glass32 ๐ฅ Glass+ ๐๏ธ Sand= โ Hourglass33 ๐ฅ Fire+ โ Hourglass= โฐ Time34 ๐ Ash+ โฐ Time= ๐ History35 ๐ฅ Glass+ ๐จ Steam= ๐ช Mirror36 ๐ History+ ๐ช Mirror= ๐ Past37 ๐ฅ Fire+ ๐จ Wind= ๐จ Smoke38 ๐จ Smoke+ ๐ง Water= ๐ซ๏ธ Fog39 ๐ซ๏ธ Fog+ ๐ฑ Plant= ๐ Mushroom40 ๐ Earth+ ๐ Mushroom= ๐ Toadstool41 ๐ผ Dandelion+ ๐ฑ Plant= ๐ฟ Weed42 ๐ Toadstool+ ๐ฟ Weed= ๐ Magic Mushroom43 ๐ซ๏ธ Dust+ ๐จ Wind= ๐ช๏ธ Sandstorm44 ๐ช๏ธ Sandstorm+ ๐ง Water= ๐๏ธ Oasis45 ๐๏ธ Oasis+ ๐ฑ Plant= ๐ Date46 ๐ Date+ ๐ง Water= ๐ Dating47 ๐ Dating+ ๐ Earth= ๐ Marriage48 ๐ Earth+ ๐ Marriage= ๐ Divorce49 ๐ผ Dandelion+ ๐ซ๏ธ Dust= ๐ Wish50 ๐ง Water+ ๐ Wish= ๐งโโ๏ธ Genie51 ๐ Divorce+ ๐งโโ๏ธ Genie= ๐ Single52 ๐ Magic Mushroom+ ๐ Single= ๐ธ Triple53 ๐ Past+ ๐ธ Triple= ๐ค Past Tense54 ๐ค Doubter+ ๐ค Past Tense= ๐ Past DoubterCrafting tree 1 Fire + Water โ Steam 2 Earth + Steam โ Mud 3 Fire + Mud โ Brick 4 Earth + Water โ Plant 5 Plant + Wind โ Dandelion 6 Dandelion + Water โ Wine 7 Water + Wine โ Holy Water 8 Brick + Holy Water โ Church 9 Earth + Wind โ Dust 10 Fire + Steam โ Engine 11 Dust + Engine โ Vacuum 12 Vacuum + Water โ Sponge 13 Sponge + Steam โ SpongeBob 14 Earth + SpongeBob โ Patrick 15 Engine + Steam โ Train 16 Patrick + Train โ Thomas 17 Church + Thomas โ Doubt 18 Plant + Water โ Swamp 19 Fire + Swamp โ Dragon 20 Water + Wind โ Wave 21 Earth + Wave โ Sand 22 Sand + Water โ Beach 23 Dust + Earth โ Planet 24 Fire + Planet โ Sun 25 Beach + Sun โ Vacation 26 Engine + Vacation โ Retirement 27 Earth + Retirement โ Pension 28 Dragon + Pension โ Retired 29 Doubt + Retired โ Doubter 30 Dust + Fire โ Ash 31 Fire + Sand โ Glass 32 Glass + Sand โ Hourglass 33 Fire + Hourglass โ Time 34 Ash + Time โ History 35 Glass + Steam โ Mirror 36 History + Mirror โ Past 37 Fire + Wind โ Smoke 38 Smoke + Water โ Fog 39 Fog + Plant โ Mushroom 40 Earth + Mushroom โ Toadstool 41 Dandelion + Plant โ Weed 42 Toadstool + Weed โ Magic Mushroom 43 Dust + Wind โ Sandstorm 44 Sandstorm + Water โ Oasis 45 Oasis + Plant โ Date 46 Date + Water โ Dating 47 Dating + Earth โ Marriage 48 Earth + Marriage โ Divorce 49 Dandelion + Dust โ Wish 50 Water + Wish โ Genie 51 Divorce + Genie โ Single 52 Magic Mushroom + Single โ Triple 53 Past + Triple โ Past Tense 54 Doubter + Past Tense โ Past Doubter
Advertisement space reserved
Other ways to make Past Doubter 2 combinations are known to produce Past Doubter. Here are 2 of them.
Past Doubter at a glance
Steps to craft 54 Marathon
Crafting depth 80 longer than 99% of solved elements
Known recipes 2 ways to make it
Used in 0 other combinations Other elements that take 54 steps Similar effort to Past Doubter, if you want something else to chase.
Frequently asked questions How do you make Past Doubter in Infinite Craft? Combine Doubter with Past Tense. The full path from the base elements takes 54 steps.
How many steps does it take to make Past Doubter? 54 steps on the shortest known path from Water, Fire, Wind and Earth.
Is Past Doubter hard to make in Infinite Craft? It rates as marathon. At 54 steps it is longer than 99% of solved elements.
Is there more than one way to make Past Doubter? Yes. 2 combinations are known to produce Past Doubter, and the shortest route is shown above.
Path verified against the open recipe graph on 2026-10-24 . Method described in our methodology , data credited on data sources .